This is a video tutorial you can watch here: [link]
Eye Vectors: [link]
Pony Patterns: [link]
This is a video explaining how I do the eyes on my pony plush. I also use this method for my other plushies that have detailed faces. So if you don't like iron on transfers, you can't paint well at all, and you're terrible at hand-embroidery, this is probably a good method for you!
Pony patterns in my store! [link]
Please read the comments, your question may have already been answered!